Winner! Winner! Where are the Most Scrumptious Pies in Ocean County

Thank you for all your votes, we have a WINNER of the best pies in Ocean County.

There was a top 5 - Emery's Farm, Sand Castle Diner, Lucille's, Costco, and Mueller's Bakery.

Get our free mobile app

Lots of votes came in and we have a WINNER. Congratulations to Emery's Farm in New Egypt. If you've never tried the pies at Emery's, they are superb. My family always asks for me to grab a pie on my way to Pennsylvania, they know good pies.

I was talking to Linda from Brick in BJ's in Toms River and we were talking about pies. I thought this would be a great article. Where are the "best" pies in Ocean County? Linda was telling me that the pies at BJ's and Costco are the biggest and the best. I had to try a pie from Costco and Linda was right, delicious.

Pies are the staple for holidays, BBQs, and everything else when it comes to family and friends. A good piece of pie was my Dad's favorite. A good piece of apple pie is what he always ordered when we were out to dinner.

We love our pie in New Jersey and not just pizza pie. New Jersey's favorite pies are cherry, apple, and pumpkin. Key Lime is up there, too for a favorite of a lot of my co-workers. "Thank you" to the awesome "PIE" places in Ocean County, especially our top 5 - Emery's Farm, Sand Castle Diner, Lucille's, Costco, and Mueller's Bakery.

Emery's Farm is located at 346 Long Swamp Road in New Egypt, NJ. Their phone number is (609) 758-8514.

Listen to Shawn & Sue mornings on 92.7 WOBM and download our free 92.7 WOBM app.