The Search for New Jersey’s Best Christmas Cookies Is On — Here’s Who Makes the Cut

What Makes a Christmas Cookie Truly Great?

The holiday season is here, and that means lots of amazing Christmas cookies. If you’re looking for the best treats in New Jersey, there are plenty of great bakeries to check out. Enjoy a variety of styles and tastes this Christmas.

Get our free mobile app

Growing up here in New Jersey, we always had the best Christmas cookies, whether it was baked at home or at one of the many great bakeries; nothing could beat a cold glass of milk and a plate of Christmas cookies.

Searching for the Best Christmas Cookies in New Jersey

If you love classic Italian Christmas cookies, New Jersey has tons of Italian bakeries to choose from. Calandra’s Bakery, with locations in Newark, Fairfield, and Caldwell, is known for its rainbow cookies, pignoli cookies, and soft butter cookies. They often have festive cookie trays ready to take home.

Local Bakeries Compete for Holiday Cookie Honors

In North Jersey, Balthazar Bakery in Englewood offers tasty European-style cookies, like rich shortbread and detailed gingerbread. In Central Jersey, The Gingered Peach in Lawrenceville is a local favorite, famous for its fun and creative holiday treats. In South Jersey, check out La Scala Bakery in Toms River.

And don’t forget the small hometown bakeries all over the state. They make everything from classic sugar cookies with sprinkles to chocolate crinkles and gingerbread men—simple, cozy treats that feel like home.

No matter where you are in New Jersey, from Bergen County to Cape May, grab a hot cocoa and enjoy finding your new favorite Christmas cookies. I grab a nice coffee, please.