The Most Popular Bagel Shop In New Jersey 

If you’ve spent more than five minutes in New Jersey, you already know the deal: bagels aren’t just breakfast—they’re basically a lifestyle.

Get our free mobile app

Whether you're grabbing a quick bite on your way to hit the Parkway or standing in line on a Saturday morning with the rest of the neighborhood, fresh bagels are just baked right into the fabric of the Garden State.

According to Shane Co., the most popular bagel in the Garden State is the "everything" bagel. This one is a hugely popular flavor, and with a good cream cheese, you have a really delicious bagel.

Plain cream cheese is the popular choice in New Jersey.

The protein topping is very "Jersey" too: pork roll with egg and cheese. More like a round sub than a usual breakfast bagel lol

Where Is The Best Bagel Shop In New Jersey?

A post by FinanceBuzz selected a bagel shop in Monmouth County as the place to visit for delicious bagels in Jersey. "Bagels are one of the most beloved breakfast staples that help you stretch your food budget. Across the United States, each state offers its own twist on this classic treat."

The report cited Bagel Masters in Shrewsbury as a great place for a delicious bagel. "Renowned for its oversized, fluffy bagels, Bagel Masters offers a delightful variety of flavors and toppings and maintains a 4.6 Google rating."

Bagel Masters is located at 661 Broad St, Shrewsbury, NJ 07702. Follow them on Facebook and Instagram.

Where is your go-to bagel shop? Give us your recommendations.