This is the Best Bagel Restaurant in Toms River, NJ, Chosen By You

Bagels are a favorite of New Jerseyans. We have the "best" bagels anywhere on this planet.

When I visit friends in the south such as in Florida and North Carolina, they always ask me to bring the bagels. They used to live in New Jersey and they know the best is right here in New Jersey.

Get our free mobile app

When it comes to New Jersey and our bagels, the egg bagel and the everything bagel are the most popular. Cream cheese is the most popular topping and flavored cream cheese.

Recently we had our Shawn & Sue Poll for "best bagels" and the winner of our Annual Best Bagels in Ocean County was New York Water Bagel in Toms River. The Top 5 winners in Ocean County - New York Water Bagel, Silver Bay Bagel, JT's, Bagels & Beyond, and Barons.

Danielle from Lanoka Harbor: Jt bagels in lacey they r the best bagels around they have great everything bagels and french toast bagels omg so good made every morning fresh too.

Mary from Brick: Seriously people?? Barons on 88 in Point.. nothing better.

Vicki from Toms River: Silver Bay Bagels - More specifically their Everything Bagel.

Where's the "Best" bagel in Toms River chosen by you?

Hands down, this question brings so many votes, where's the best bagel? There is one bagel in Toms River that always seems to win and it was chosen by you. It's New York Water Bagel.

Their pork roll egg and cheese is one of the best in Ocean County. Their sandwiches are always huge.