Miss Mindy’s All-Ice-Cream Thanksgiving Pie in Bayville, NJ

Have you ever seen a Thanksgiving dessert quite like this? New Jersey just got sweeter.

AND, Thanksgiving Just Got Sweeter: Miss Mindy’s Ice Cream Pies Are Here!

Bayville locals and surrounding areas know that Miss Mindy’s Ice Cream isn’t just any ice cream shop, it’s a wonderland of flavor, fun, and creativity. And this year, they’re taking Thanksgiving to the next level with their Thanksgiving Pie, made entirely of ice cream! CHECK THIS OUT! 👇👇

Picture this: all the creamy, dreamy goodness of homemade ice cream, expertly blended into a festive pie that’s perfect for the holiday table. Whether you’re a pumpkin fan, a chocolate lover, or a traditionalist, Miss Mindy’s pies promise to be the centerpiece of your Thanksgiving feast.

It’s never too early to plan your holiday dessert! Pre-order your Thanksgiving Pie by November 21st, 2025 to guarantee a sweet ending to your family celebration.

Call Miss Mindy's or stop by at 155 Rt. 9 in Bayville, NJ, your taste buds will thank you.

Miss Mindy’s is famous for more than just their Thanksgiving Pie. With a wide array of homemade ice cream flavors and a playful, creative approach to ice cream and goodies, every visit feels like a mini celebration.

This Thanksgiving, make your dessert the star of the show with a one-of-a-kind ice cream pie that everyone will love.

Don’t wait, place your order today and make your holiday feast extra special with Miss Mindy’s unforgettable ice cream creations!

IN PHOTOS: 100 Years of the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade

Stacker curated a selection of photographs from the past century of the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade to help illustrate the history of the iconic event.

Gallery Credit: Stacker